| Rank | Team Name | Total Score |
| 1 | Stefan's Dream 23: Stefan Ex Machina | 8,585 |
| 2 | It Just Doesn't Matter | 8,125 |
| 3 | Meyer Meyer Pants on Fire | 7,930 |
| 4 | Sigma Phi Nothing | 7,850 |
| 5 | Voodoo Panties | 7,805 |
| 6 | Pull-Start Diesel | 7,680 |
| 7 | What Would Learned Pigs and Scooby Doo? | 7,245 |
| 8 | "Popcorn" is a good song | 7,095 |
| 9 | Neo-Maxi Zoomdweebies | 6,945 |
| 10 | Mongo's Loosemeat Sandwich Assembly RQD | 6,935 |
| 11 | ET: Late Night Library Liaisons with Big Titles and Long Pen Names | 6,775 |
| 12 | House of Insanity | 6,710 |
| 13 | Nonessential Government Workers | 6,265 |
| 14 | Nerd Party | 6,195 |
| 15 | Our BoobTube Likes BigBooksandCanNotLie | 6,105 |
| 16 | Moby Dick and a Boatload of Seamen | 5,990 |
| 17 | Do Trivia Teams Dream of Electric Ditkas? | 5,760 |
| 18 | We Wish That We Were Jessie's Squirrels | 5,540 |
| 19 | LDE liked the movie better | 5,460 |
| 20 | The Lion, the Witch, and the Liquor Cabinet | 5,405 |
| 21 | Nancy Drew and The Hardy Boys | 5,310 |
| 22 | Google Your Own Adventure | 5,245 |
| 23 | There's always money in the banana stand | 4,880 |
| 24 | Knee Deep in Theses | 4,550 |
| 25 | Porcupine Petting Zoo | 4,455 |
| 26 | Six Feet Under | 4,440 |
| 27 | Pirates of the Cranium | 4,415 |
| 28 | Fits of Conniption | 4,350 |
| 29 | DDD - Hamster Hears A Who | 4,155 |
| 30 | Warm Goat Springs University | 3,910 |
| 31 | E=MCHammered | 3,810 |
| 32 | Bookaholix: A Few Screws Loose | 3,775 |
| 33 | Year 4: Prose Before Hoes | 3,460 |
| 34 | PigBoats.com/LITerally A Book Club | 3,430 |
| 35 | Shaggy 2 Dope and the Goblet of Faygo | 3,380 |
| 36 | Rich Corinthian Leather Remnants | 3,315 |
| 37 | Crockpot Posse | 2,895 |
| 38 | Freaks & Geeks: When in Doubt, Go to the Library | 2,890 |
| 39 | Backstage Bibliophiles | 2,855 |
| 40 | Awkward Turtle Heads | 2,545 |
| 41 | Salmonella Fitzgerald: An Oral History | 2,395 |
| 42 | Hill Case 91-92 | 2,305 |
| 43 | The Results of the Trouble Among the Cheerleaders | 2,275 |
| 44 | Main Street Irregulars | 2,235 |
| 45 | Enjoy the Man Explosion! | 2,070 |
| 46 | Three Sheets FTW | 1,920 |
| 47 | Far Q: De you even book bro? | 1,775 |
| 48 | The Quizzard of Oz | 920 |
| 49 | The Tune Squad | 820 |
| 50 | The Illiterates | 790 |
| 51 | To Kill a Mockingnerd | 75 |